Back to HostaLibrary

Back to Recipe Homepage

   A long time ago Bill was actually young and he went to a bar looking for a coworker. Said coworker wasn't there and Bill decided to have a beer. The bartender asked if he'd like some French Onion soup. The soup had been on the burner all day and had reduced to a thick soup with fantastic flavor. When he and Carol got together they began a long process of trying to make an equally good one. This is the result of their efforts after many adjustments.  

NOTE --- Updated with improved technique..

                   Our French Onion Soup
                             Bill and Carol
approx. 4lbs yellow onions  
1 stick butter (1/4 pound)        1/2 tbs salt
3 quarts beef broth
beef bones, fat *
1/8 cup molasses 
1/4 cup brown sugar
3/4 cup sherry   3/4 cup red wine
1 slice white bread 
2 Tbs grated parmesan
Gruyere or Mozzarella for topping

Instructions

Cut onions fairly large. The best method for cooking them is to put them and the butter and salt into a crock pot for 24 hours on low. Stir occasionally. Keep an eye on things the first time as some crock pots run pretty hot on low and watch for burning. 

*For this a pound or so of bones, fat, with maybe little meat. Roast that at 400F for 20 minutes

The next day add the beef broth, wines, molasses, bones/fat, half the onions and all the liquid from the onions. Get pot to a low simmer (just a little bubbling). Use a wooden skewer and mark it to show the depth of the soup.  Cook at that temp until the level has dropped 20-30%. That is cooking off water and making the flavor richer and more intense. It will be a few hours or so.    

Remove 2 cups of broth and put it and the bread into a blender. Blend until smooth - this will thicken the soup. Return to soup and add the parmesan. Add the rest of the onions and cook another 30 minutes or so.

To serve toast a slice of French bread until tan and top with either the Gruyere or Mozzarella in the bowl. a quick trip to the broiler to brown the cheese adds flavor. 

Notes - We use Tabathnik beef broth, and haven't tried some of the newer beef bone broths. Those could be even better.